Pizza Menu

    • Pizza

      Hand tossed dough that is fresh made daily and cold risen for 48 hours. Our homemade "no heartburn" pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious 3-cheese blend.

    • Create your own pizza

      Create your own pizza

      Hand tossed dough that is made fresh daily and cold risen for 48 hours. Our homemade “no heartburn” pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious three-cheese blend. Add toppings to make it yours!
      Be aware - pizzas ordered on a thin crust will not enjoy the same heat retention as our original crust.

       
      Small Medium Large Big Papa Personal
      Size 10" 12" 14" Sheet 8"
      Slices 6 8 10 32 4
      Cheese Price 8.49 11.49 13.49 27.99 4.99
      Toppings 1.50 1.75 2.25 5.00 0.60

      * Thin crust available in medium only
      * Cauliflower crust available in small only
      * Heart pizza available in large only

    • Pizza Toppings

      Meats: Pepperoni - Ham - Sausage - Ground Beef - Bacon - Anchovies - Gyro Meat* - Chicken* - Meatballs*

      Vegetables: Mushroom - Green Pepper - Onion - Black Olives - Kalamata Olives - Mild Banana Peppers - Jalapenos - Roma Tomato - Pineapple - Spinach - Broccoli - Fresh Basil

      Cheese: Extra Cheese - Feta Cheese - Cheddar Cheese - Parmesan Cheese

      (* These items are so good they count as 2 toppings!)

    • Specialty Pizzas 10" 10.49 12" 15.49 14" 18.49 BP 38.99

    • 5 Cheese Pepperoni

      5 Cheese Pepperoni

      Love cheese? Love Pepperoni? We thought so! We use our 3-cheese blend, add extra pepperoni, cheddar and Parmesan cheeses.

    • 7 Cheesy Cheese

      7 Cheesy Cheese

      For the cheese lovers, this pizza is for you! We top our fresh dough and sauce with 7 cheeses: Mozzarella, Provolone, Muenster, Cheddar, Feta, Parmesan, Romano & EXTRA Cheese!

    • BBQ Chicken Pizza

      BBQ Chicken Pizza

      We start with a sweet BBQ sauce and add three cheeses, red onions, chicken and bacon. After it's baked we add another splattering of BBQ sauce.

    • Buffalo Chicken

      Buffalo Chicken

      Pizza with a little kick to it! Buffalo sauce covered with chicken, red onion, cheddar cheese and our 3-cheese blend. Topped with ranch dressing.

    • Hawaiian Pizza

      Hawaiian Pizza

      You've never had one like this before. Pizza sauce with our 3-cheese blend, ham, crispy bacon and lots of pineapple. We add sliced almonds and top it with cinnamon-sugar!

    • Margherita Pizza

      Margherita Pizza

      This pizza's history dates back to 1889. The red tomatoes, white fresh mozzarella cheese and green basil represent the colors of the Italian flag. Served in 12" size on thin crust or 10" size on cauliflower crust.
      Click for more information about the Margherita pizza

    • Monster Roni

      Monster Roni

      We use a Monster-sized pepperoni on this along with our regular portion of pepperoni and extra cheese. Enjoy the layers of flavors!

    • The Brier Hill

      The Brier Hill

      A unique Youngstown pizza classic on a thick crust, a more traditional Italian "Sunday Sauce", lighter Parmesan cheese with sliced meatballs and fresh green peppers.

    • Tiki Torcher

      Tiki Torcher

      We start with a Hawaiian pizza and instead of the almonds and cinnamon-sugar we add JALAPENOS and RED PEPPER FLAKES. The sweet perfectly balances the spicy.

    • Veggie Pizza

      Veggie Pizza

      For those looking for a healthier option: pizza sauce covered with 3 cheeses, red onion, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, black olives and roma tomatoes.

    • Papa's Favorite Pizzas 10" 11.49 12" 16.49 14" 20.49 BP 41.99

    • CBR1000CR

      CBR1000CR

      A ranch sauce covered with 3 cheeses, double bacon, and chicken. Once baked we finish it with a homemade chipotle ranch swirl!

    • Chicken Broccoli Melt Pizza

      Chicken Broccoli Melt Pizza

      Our homemade garlic butter sauce covered with spinach, broccoli, chicken, mushrooms and cheese.

    • Chicken Philly Pizza

      Chicken Philly Pizza

      We start with a creamy cheese sauce and load it with red onion, green peppers, mushrooms, grilled chicken and our 3 cheese blend.

    • Chipotle Steak Pizza

      Chipotle Steak Pizza

      A garlic butter cheese sauce with steak, mushrooms, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese and a chipotle ranch swirl on top!

    • Deluxe Pizza

      Deluxe Pizza

      The classic - pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, red onion and crumbled sausage.

    • Gold Rush

      Gold Rush

      Enjoy the sweetness of GOLD. Carolina gold sauce topped with our 3 cheese blend, cheddar cheese, grilled chicken, pineapple and mild banana peppers. Scott's favorite.

    • Gyro Pizza

      Gyro Pizza

      This pizza is amazing, but don't take our word for it. A THIN crust with tzatziki sauce, red onion, gyro meat, kalamata olives, feta cheese and roma tomatoes. PIZZA IS ALWAYS SERVED ON THIN CRUST in 12" size only.

    • Meat Eaters

      Meat Eaters

      For the carnivore in you! Pizza sauce, 3 cheeses, pepperoni, crumbled sausage, diced ham and crispy bacon. How can you go wrong with that?

    • Meaty Menser

      Meaty Menser

      This is a creation of our manager, Tim. Crumbled ground beef, crisp bacon and crumbled sausage start it off. It's then topped with pepperoni for a crispy bite. After baking we turn up the heat by adding special hot spices!

    • Spinach Chicken Pizza

      Spinach Chicken Pizza

      Our homemade garlic butter sauce covered with our 3 cheese blend, chicken, fresh mushrooms, spinach and parmesan cheese.

    • The Gym

      The Gym

      Inspired by a fellow gym goer. The perfect balance of protein and green vegetables. Pizza sauce, cheese, pepperoni, chicken, spinach and broccoli. Not your typical pizza combination, but it is delicious!

    • Garden Fresh Salads

    • Antipasto Salad

      $8.49

      Iceberg and romaine lettuce, Roma tomatoes, red onion, ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, our 3-cheese blend, black olives and a pepperoncini pepper.

    • Buffalo Chicken Salad

      $8.49

      Iceberg and romaine lettuce, roma tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, feta cheese, crispy buffalo chicken & a pepperoncini pepper.

    • Chef Salad

      $8.49

      Iceberg and romaine lettuce, roma tomatoes, red onions, ham, turkey, cheddar cheese, black olives and a pepperoncini pepper.

    • Garden Salad

      $8.49
      $4.25

      Iceberg and romaine lettuce, roma tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, our 3-cheese blend, black olives and a pepperoncini pepper.

    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      $8.49

      Iceberg and romaine lettuce, roma tomatoes, red onions, grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, and black olives.

    • Cheese Bread & Bread Stix

    • 4 Cheese Bread

      $7.69 Dozen
      $6.19 Half Doz

      Pizza dough covered with garlic butter, our 3-cheese blend, cheddar, Parmesan and Romano cheese. Served with marinara dipping sauce.

    • Bacon Cheese Bread

      $7.69 Dozen
      $6.19 Half Doz

      Pizza dough covered with garlic butter, our 3-cheese blend, cheddar, bacon, Parmesan and Romano cheese. Served with marinara dipping sauce.

    • Garlic Stix

      $5.19 Dozen
      $4.19 Half Doz

      Pizza dough topped with garlic butter, parmesan and romano cheeses. Served with marinara sauce on the side.

    • Pepperoni Cheese Bread

      $7.69 Dozen
      $6.19 Half Doz

      Pizza dough covered with garlic butter, our 3-cheese blend, cheddar, pepperoni, Parmesan and Romano cheese. Served with marinara dipping sauce.

    • Caramel Cinnamon-streusel stix

      $5.19 Dozen
      $4.19 Half Doz

      Pizza dough covered with butter, cinnamon-sugar & a homemade streusel topping, drizzled with caramel after baking. Served with icing on the side.

    • Raspberry Stix

      $5.19 Dozen
      $4.19 Half Doz

      Pizza dough covered with sugar, butter and raspberry topping. Served with icing on the side.

    • Pasta / Meatballs

    • Deluxe MagicRoni and Cheese

      $11.99

      A delicious portion of our white cheddar macaroni and cheese with fresh broccoli, bacon and grilled chicken.

    • MagicRoni and Cheese

      $8.49

      A generous portion of delicious white cheddar macaroni and cheese.

    • Meatball Bowl

      Meatball Bowl

      $6.99

      Enjoy 12 whole meatballs baked with your choice of sauce. Add cheese if you wish!

    • Pasta

      Pasta

      $7.49

      Penne served with our marinara or garlic butter.

      Add meatballs, ground sausage, chicken, mushroom, or spinach as you like. Also available baked with cheese.

      Trays of pasta available, please pre-order, we need up to 1 hour to make them.

    • Buffalo Chicken MagicRoni and Cheese

      $11.99

      A delicious portion of our white cheddar macaroni and cheese with buffalo chicken and feta cheese.

    • Chicken Wings

      Oven baked bone-in chicken wings and boneless dippin chicken

    • Dippin Chicken

      $6.49 6pc
      $11.99 12pc
      $21.99 24pc

      Oven baked boneless chicken wings. Served plain with sauce on the side to dip.

      6 piece come with 1 free sauce. 12 piece comes with 2 free sauces. 24 piece comes with 3 free sauces.

    • Wings

      $6.50 1/2lb (4-6)
      $12.99 1lb (8-12)
      $24.99 2lb (16-24)

      Bone-in chicken wings perfectly baked through the oven and tossed in your choice of sauce.

      Sauces listed mildest to wildest:

      Naked - Dry Rub Ranch - Garlic Parmesan - BBQ - Carolina Gold - Sweet Red Chili - Spicy Garlic - Buffalo

    • Papa Roni Roll

    • Papa Roni Roll

      $5.99

      Pepperoni and our 3-cheese blend stuffed inside freshly made pizza dough rolled up and topped with Italian seasoning then baked to perfection. Served with your choice of 2 side sauces. No additions or substitutions.

    • Jalapeno Popper Roni Roll

      $5.99

      In the mood for some Jalapeno poppers? Look no further! This Jalapeno Popper Roni Roll is as close as you can get without the fryer. We roll up a pizza dough and stuff it with 2 different cheeses and jalapenos. Served with 2 sides of Ranch for your dipping pleasure.

    • 4 PACK Papa Roni Rolls

      $22.00

      A 4 pack of our soon to be famous Papa Roni Rolls. These are served 4 IN 1 BOX and come with a total of 8 dipping sauce cups.

    • Oven Baked Subs

      Calzone-style oven baked subs.

    • Buffalo Chicken Sub

      $8.99

      Grilled chicken breast pieces covered with buffalo sauce and our 3-cheese blend. Topped with lettuce and tomato, served with a side of blue cheese.

    • Chicken Cordon Gold

      $8.99

      Try our delicious take on a Chicken Cordon Bleu. Grilled chicken topped with gold sauce, white American cheese and ham. Lettuce and tomatoes after baked plus mayonnaise

    • Chipotle Steak Sub

      $8.99

      Our perfectly seasoned steak topped with white American cheese, banana peppers and mushrooms. Served with chipotle ranch on the side.

    • Italian Sub

      $8.99

      Ham, Genoa Salami and white American cheese. Topped with lettuce & tomatoes, Italian dressing on the side.

    • Meatball Sub

      $8.49

      Marinara sauce, all-beef meatballs and our 3-cheese blend.

    • Philly Steak Sub

      $8.99

      Our perfectly seasoned steak topped with white American cheese, grilled green peppers and onions. Served with mayonnaise on the side.

    • Pizza Sub

      $7.99

      Pizza sauce and our 3-cheese blend are standard. Add any 3 topping of your choice.

    • Spicy Italian Sub

      $8.99

      Ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, mild peppers, white American cheese, lettuce, roma tomatoes and Italian dressing.

    • Turkey Club

      $8.99

      Turkey, Ham, white American cheese and Bacon. Topped with lettuce & tomatoes, mayonnaise on the side.

    • Ultimate BLT

      $8.99

      Bacon, Cheddar and our 3-cheese blend. Topped with lettuce & tomatoes, mayonnaise on the side.

    • Veggie Sub

      $7.99

      Fresh Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Banana Peppers, Cheddar Cheese and our 3-cheese blend. Topped with lettuce & tomatoes, Italian dressing on the side.

    • Gyros

    • Chicken Gyro

      $7.99

      Grilled Chicken Breast, Red Onions, Roma Tomatoes, & Tzatziki Sauce served on a 7" handmade pita. Try it with Kalamata Olives & Feta Cheese to make it a Deluxe Gyro.

    • Gyro

      $7.49

      Traditional gyro meat, red onions, roma tomatoes & tzatziki sauce served on a 7" handmade pita. Try it with kalamata olives & feta cheese to make it a deluxe gyro.

x