Ice Cream Menu

    • Ice Cream Flavors

    • Katie's Korner Ice Cream

      For a list of all our current and seasonal flavors, please visit our online ordering website https://paparonis.hungerrush.com/Order/Menu/1#icecream

      • Vanilla Nothing "Vanilla" about ours. It's a true PREMIUM ICE CREAM. Used in our cones, sundaes, and milkshakes. No filler here!
      • Banana The delicious creamy flavor of FRESH bananas. Not banana syrup or flavoring.
      • Black Raspberry Cheesecake A vanilla ice cream swirled with black raspberry and creamy cheesecake.
      • Butter Pecan One of the top 3 flavors in the USA. A buttery ice cream loaded with delicious whole pecans.
      • Cake Batter A super-sweet cake batter flavored ice cream with rainbow sprinkles throughout.
      • Cappuccino Fudge Love coffee? Love fudge? You'll LOVE this combination!
      • Caramel Cashew A vanilla ice cream base swirled with gooey caramel and whole cashews.
      • Cherry White House A creamy cherry/vanilla ice cream with large chunks of maraschino cherries throughout.
      • Chocolate Enough said!
      • Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Just what the name says. Kids of ALL AGES love it!
      • Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter #1 SELLER A decadent rich DARK chocolate ice cream swirled with smooth peanut butter.
      • Mint Chocolate Chip Abundant dark chocolate chips mixed into mint ice cream.
      • Moose Trax Vanilla ice cream swirled with chocolate fudge and loaded with peanut butter cups.
      • Oreo Cookies N Cream The great taste of oreo cookies blended into smooth vanilla ice cream.
      • Reeses Peanut Butter Cup A RICH, peanut butter ice cream with chunks of Reeses peanut butter cups throughout.
      • Strawberry Strawberry flavored ice cream with real strawberries mixed in.
      • Superman A colorful blend of yellow (lemon), red (cherry), and blue (blue raspberry) ice creams.
      • Vanilla Yogurt
    • Ice Cream

    • Ice Cream

      $Single 3.75
      $Double 5.00
      $Triple 6.50
      $Junior 2.50

      Cake Cone
      Sugar Cone
      Bowl
      Waffle Cone (add 1.00)

    • Pint / Quart

      $Pint 6.49
      $Quart 9.99

      Choose any of the 20+ flavors of delicious Katie's Korner ice cream that we serve and have it delivered with your order! Pints and quarts are packed by weight, not volume.

    • Sundaes

    • Banana Split

      $8.49

      A traditional banana split: Chocolate, Vanilla and Strawberry ice cream topped with Chocolate syrup, Pineapple and Strawberry. Covered with Whipped Cream, Nuts and a Cherry!

    • Bananas Foster Sundae

      $Regular 7.00
      $Large 8.25

      Vanilla ice cream, Banana, Caramel, Whipped Cream, Cinnamon and a Cherry.

    • Buckeye Sundae

      $Regular 7.00
      $Large 8.25

      Vanilla ice cream with Hot Fudge, Reeses Peanut Butter, Buckeyes, Whipped Cream & a Cherry.

    • BYO Banana Split

      $9.49

      Build your own: Your choice of 3 ice cream flavors & 3 toppings. Comes with Whipped Cream, Nuts and a Cherry

    • Cookie Monster

      $Large 8.22
      $Large 8.25

      Oreo and cookie dough ice cream, chocolate Syrup, Oreo Topping, whipped Cream and a cherry.

    • Sundaes

      $Regular 5.00
      $Large 6.25

      Choose from: hot fudge, caramel, chocolate syrup, strawberries, raspberry syrup, peanut butter, pineapple, butterscotch, Buckeyes, or Oreo topping to go with your vanilla ice cream, whipped cream and a cherry.

    • Turtle Sundae

      $Regular 7.00
      $Large 8.25

      Vanilla ice cream with Hot Fudge, Creamy Caramel, Pecans, Whipped Cream & a Cherry.

    • Milkshakes

    • Milkshake

      $16oz Medium 4.50
      $20oz Large 5.50

      Our old-fashioned milkshakes are hand-dipped and spun, just like your grandparents would have enjoyed. Choose from any of our 20+ ice cream flavors for your milkshake.

    • Root Beer Float

      $20oz Large 4.50

      Turn back the time to your childhood with a Root Beer float. Or mix it up and choose any ice cream along with your choice of pop to go with it!

x